Here’s my pattern review for McCalls M5525:
Semi fitted, double breasted, lined trench coat
Multi Size: Sizes 8 to 16. I cut a size 14 – with hindsight I should have cut a 16 or at least done a FBA. it is on the snug side.
Did it look like the photo/drawing on the pattern envelope once you were done sewing with it?
Yes it did! Except for the buckles that I added. The original pattern has buttoned carriers instead.
Were the instructions easy to follow?
Generally the instructions were pretty easy to follow. However when it came to attaching the shoulder straps, it completely omitted that step and it wasn’t until I had attached the sleeves that I worked out that you were supposed to attach the shoulder straps at the same time as easing in the sleeves….!
What did you particularly like or dislike about the pattern?
It’s a pretty classic trench, which is what I was after. What I hated – easing the sleeves in – one word – horrid! And the other, the amount of topstitching that I had to do. Plus despite a new needle and proper thread, my machine really does not like top stitching.
Waterproof fabric which is shiny on one side and matt on the other. It has a lovely silky feel. I used the matt side. No idea what the fibre composition is I’m afraid, except that it was Prada! The lining is quite a thin silky material most likely Polyester, I picked this up for a £1 in a church sale. The buckles are from Klein’s – a haberdashery in London.
Pattern alterations or any design changes you made:
I used View E, but added the storm flap from View B and added buckles to the belt and sleeve straps. I also decided I didn’t like the pocket flaps and topstitched two rectangles instead. I should really have made a FBA adjustment on this and am annoyed with myself for not doing that!
Would you sew it again? Would you recommend it to others?
I probably wouldn’t sew this again in a hurry. It’s ok but fiddly. But then that is probably because I over complicate things!
I’m really relieved it’s finished. Not going to be in a hurry to make this coat again but I know it will come in handy here in wet and windy England!